New Gulf Oil Spill Idea Wiki. Submit Your Fix Idea and Collaborate Now!

  Posted by - May 15, 2010 at 11:39 pm - Permalink - Source via Alexander Higgins Blog
Share
Rate This Post 1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading ... Loading ...

UPDATE!!

Since a reader has posted they already set up a wiki I ported the content from my wiki to that one.

Having two separate wikis defeats the purpose of having a single point of collaboration.

There are a lot of good ideas on the wiki and I encourage you to drop by, review the current solutions, add your feed back and submit your ideas.

The new wiki is here: oilspill.wikia.com


First, let me start with a little rant.

BP Asks For Ideas Capping Gulf Oil Spill… But Are They Serious?

Personally, I have several ideas on how to cap the Gulf oil spill and I am sure there are millions of others that do as well.

Even even if people don’t have ideas to suggest, there are plenty of people that are more than willing to contribute.

Let me give you an example right here, right now buy doing both!

If BP is seriously asking for help, then why are they hindering those from whom they are seeking help from actually helping them.

Before I continue with my rant about BP let me announce that after reading about there request for help via twitter 4 minutes ago I have setup a Gulf Spill Wiki at http://SpillWiki.AlexanderHiggins.com where those interested can truly suggest and collaborate on ideas to fix the Gulf oil spill.

BrunoFans
Central Command Turns To Twitter To Solve The Gulf Oil Spill. Uh … http://bit.ly/bLReUR

Before I continue my rant, let me explain why open and transparent collaboration is needed to solve this mess.

BP has been continually resistant to releasing information that would actually contribute to coming to a viable solution.

These missing facts are indeed relevant, and indeed a pre-requisite, to coming to a solution for the problem.

For example, a 400 ton massive dome was lowered to the seafloor which didn’t work. Why can a structure of that weight not be used to crush the pipe shut?

I am almost certain that BP has considered such an option. But by not sharing the reason that option is not feasible, refinements to the suggestion can not be made until a valid solution is reached.

Scientist would most likely need scientific data about the leak to come up with ideas? The viscosity of the oil. An estimation of how much methane is coming out of the pipe. The velocity and pressure of the fluid leaking.

These missing variables combined with misinformation about the extent of the spill helps to further allude solutions.

For example, using BP’s estimates of the spill leakage, there is 3/4 of a gallon of water coming out of each of the three leaks. Mind you that a garden hose has a flow rate of 1 gallon every 10 seconds.

So if we are only looking at little more than 8 garden hoses of oil leaking, then one could hypothesize that the leak could be filled with some kind of expanding foam, much like weather sealant.

Obviously, we are dealing with much more oil at a much higher pressure and a much higher velocity.

But without accurate data it will be hard to formulate any ideas.

I am a programmer, so I will use a programmer’s analogy to summarize the problem.

At the end of the day here, this would be like Microsoft asking for programmers to help fix a massive bug in the source code of their Windows Operating System software while refusing to disclose the source code that contains the bug.

I am confident however, that through open collaboration and with the pooling and sharing of the knowledge that is publicly available such a solution will EVENTUALLY be obtained.

I am also confident that the questions that I have raised here and the Ideas that I present here can shape into living and breathing documents on the http://SpillWiki.AlexanderHiggins.com

Let us keep our fingers crossed that the collaboration bears some fruit and helps end this Catastrophic failure once and for all.

Two of my better ideas (again feasibility can not be determined without better data)

  1. Freezing The Pipe
    Perhaps this one seems like it comes out of a science fiction novel.

    While convention wisdom tells us that a frozen pipe will explode, perhaps by thinking outside of the box, we can make this work.

    For example, First we cut off the the rig where the pipe comes out of the seafloor.

    Then we shoot liquid nitrogen straight down the hole.

    When the liquid nitrogen hits the oil, and the methane it freezes it in place.

    While in a normal situation the pipe would burst, since this pipe goes 13,0000 feet straight down to the oil deposit and it is already encased with cement the pipe would not explode.

    Again, we need data on the pressure and velocity we are dealing with.

  2. Freezing The Leak ItselfThis idea would be to freeze the leak itself using liquid nitrogen then covering the frozen leak with cement.

    This would play off the previous example. But instead freezing the oil in the pipe, we essentially create a dome of ice around the top of the pipe. Then we can cover our Ice cube with steel mesh and cement or perhaps some other kind of material.

  3. The “Silver Bullet Method” This method, which I call the “Silver Bullet Method” involves plugging the pipe with a projectile.

    I am not sure why just using an high explosive to seal the rig won’t work. Initially I conceptualized mixing the explosive with an ordinance that would in effect “weld” the pipe shut.

    I also consider, wrapping a pipe bomb around the tube. This would exert inward pressure on the steel tube an in effect clamp the case tight.

    A theory has been developed on why this may not work, but it involves a catastrophic – end of life on earth – explanation, so I won’t go there… for now.

    But I am sure this has been considered by BP and others in the Government’s think tanks (the do have the think tanks working on this right?).

    However, since BP is not disclosing the ideas already submitted and hence not giving reasons why those ideas wont work, I will assume that this suggestion has been discounter and present an alternate version thereof.

    I call it the “Silver Bullet Method”.

    Again, the pipe is cut so we have only few feet of piping stick up from the bed of the sea floor.

    The pipe going from the seafloor to the oil deposit is more or less like an ice cream cone, except the top of the cone is somewhere around 2 feet wide (to tired to look up the actual numbers) and the bottom of the cone where it meats the oil deposit is about 9 inches wide.

    The idea hear is to make bullet, say as big as a telephone pole and shave it to fit to the inner dimensions of our graduated cylinder.

    I’ll let the PHD’s suggest the actual material, although this cartoon suggest the material should be cork. (A little bit of comic relief).

    We take this bullet here and we turn it into a projectile shooting it right down the shaft of the rig.

    It could get hairy. So looking at this basic concept, we can further refine it.

    Once again, we need data from BP.

    We need to make sure we don’t over shoot or risk blowing out the sides. How much pressure does this shaft support?

    In fact, perhaps slightly undershooting would work under the premise that the side of our bullet has several “fishooks” on it.

    I am thinking something like the side of a cheese grater.

    When our “silver bullet” reaches a certain point, these “hooks” actually dig into the shaft preventing our silver bullet from being shot back up the shaft.

    Even if this doesn’t contain the spill 100%, it would probably slow the flow of oil enough to get a cement line into the shaft and seal it off.

Now I will continue my rant.

Why hasn’t BP done the same? I literally took a whole 5 minutes to setup. And this was my first time ever setting up this application.

Instead they posted this catastrophe of a form that even the worse internet marketer’s in the world could tell you would not get many conversions (actual submissions).

Speaking of internet marketer’s, why haven’t they hired a professional firm to deal with this? To be honest, I haven’t seen any marketing out of BP period.

Not even PR to help them save face.

Instead, I read of ideas being submitted to which BP responded by threatening to sue the submitter if they turn the idea public.

Are you kidding me? Actually, the more I learn about this situation the less shocked I am about the most appalling of things concerning this firm and Big oil.

I’ll probably return to this rant later, but right now I am really tired.

And that Wiki is sitting there waiting for me, so let me go and learn how to use it!

Update: Back because I just can’t get this image out of my head

I was going to tear it apart and throw it in another post but… this just needs to get out. If this is what we are facing, it could explain BP’s unwillingness to cap the well.

It also means we need to get cracking on those ideas.

From Slashdot:

“Here’s a listing of several scientific and economic guides for estimating the volume of flow of the leak in the Gulf of Mexico erupting at a rate of somewhere around 1 million barrels per day. A new video released shows the largest hole spewing oil and natural gas from an aperture 5 feet in diameter at a rate of approximately 4 barrels per second. The oil coming up through 5,000 feet of pressurized salt water acts like a fractionating column. What you see on the surface is just around 20% of what is actually underneath the approximate 9,000 square miles of slick on the surface. The natural gas doesn’t bubble to the top but gets suspended in the water, depleting the oxygen from the water. BP would not have been celebrating with execs on the rig just prior to the explosion if it had not been capable producing at least 500,000 barrels per day — under control. If the rock gave way due to the out-of-control gushing (or due to a nuke being detonated to contain the leak), it could become a Yellowstone Caldera type event, except from below a mile of sea, with a 1/4-mile opening, with up to 150,000 psi of oil and natural gas behind it, from a reserve nearly as large as the Gulf of Mexico containing trillions of barrels of oil. That would be an Earth extinction event.”
 

Related Posts
Deepwater Blowout Oil Plume Simulation
Calling out BP on their outright lies has become an exercise in futility. It seems that Government, and at points the media, is just as happy to mindlessly echo the massive ...
READ MORE
Steve Wereley Congress Testimony Estimates 25000 Barrels Per Day From Single 1.2 inch Hole on BOP Rise Leak
New Government Gulf Oil Spill Flow Rates Questioned The quick version The aerial team was forced to make an estimate from a small sample of the Gulf of Mexico using new untested ...
READ MORE
BP gulf oil spill TOP KILL Diagram
Summary: A BP insider has been tweeting the situation from inside the BP command center and says due to the unknown rate of flow of the oil BP has delayed ...
READ MORE
As the condition of BP's leaking oil well continues to deteriorate rapidly BP has tried desperately to prevent the Federal Government from monitoring the sea floor for oil and ...
READ MORE
Bob Cavnar On Underground Blowout
BP has been given authorization to remove the drill pipe and the other equipment from inside of the stuck well but experts say the decision is an unneeded risk and ...
READ MORE
BP Junk shot explosion thumbnail
Summary: BP may officially announce Top Kill failed at 5:00pm and plans to proceed with Plan B. Explosions that began yesterday after the failure of several junk shot attempts continued ...
READ MORE
BP now acknowledges that it is currently siphoning 5,000 barrels of oil per day in a stark admission that it previous claims of only 5,000 barrels per day where ...
READ MORE
underwater 3D model of 22 mile long gulf oil spill plume with sea floor leaks
From The Energy Report: And just when things were looking up for the Gulf. . .a huge underwater oil plume has been discovered. The hydrocarbon plume/river is 22 miles long, 1.2 ...
READ MORE
Thomas Jefferson 3D Gulf Seafloor Leaks Mapping
There seems to be a great deal of skepticism over the possibility that cracks in the well casing and rock formation surrounding the BP Gulf Oil spill could lead to ...
READ MORE
Government Explores Plans For Pipeline Among Growing Concerns Relief Wells Will Fail To Stop Leaking Well
The list of problems that BP is facing in its battle against the leaking oil well seem to get worse everyday. Those problems only add to concerns that the relief wells ...
READ MORE
Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (WHOI) Logo
I ran across an article at Military & Aerospace Electronics magazine which brought to light the fact that after over 2 months the Government is just now issuing authorization ...
READ MORE
ROV during operation top kill has appeared to be trying to drag the steel cage toward the BOP
BP making preparations to take next step of Gulf oil spill Top Kill. If your monitoring the the BP live video feed webcam of Gulf oil spill the you can ...
READ MORE
Why Would We Lie
The rampant use of toxic dispersants, out-of-state private contractors being brought in to spray them and US Coast Guard complicity are common stories now in the four states ...
READ MORE
Bob Cavnar Drilling Industry Expert
Drilling Experts Say BP Well Is Not Dead, Static Kill has Failed, and BP Needs To Answer Questions About Clouds Coming From Sea Floor. Oil Industry Expert Bob Cavnar has ...
READ MORE
Private contractor in Carolina Skiff with tank of Corexit dispersant, August 10, south of Pass Christian Harbor, 9:30 AM. (Photo: Don Tillman)By Dahr JamailTruth-OutShirley and Don Tillman, residents of Pass ...
READ MORE
Tell President Obama Do Something Now
A new article on FishNews.eu says a new report backs claims that Gulf fisheries have been reopened too quickly. The article cites the Wenonah Hauter, the Executive Director of Food and ...
READ MORE
BP’s Lies About Methane And Oil Plumes Exposed
New Government Estimates of Gulf Oil Spill Flow
BP Gulf Oil Spill Top Kill Latest Updates
Despite Multiple Methane And Oil Leaks From BOP
BP now removing “drill pipe and OTHER EQUIPMENT”
BP Gulf oil spill junk shot explosions continue,
BP Siphon Capturing 5,000 Barrels Oil Per Day.
22 Mile Plume Of Oil From BP Gulf
NOAA Finds Several Leaks In Cracks On Gulf
Government Explores Plans For Pipeline Among Growing Concerns
Feds Grow Tired of BP Stalling Flow Rate
Live Blogging BP Live Oil Spill Video Updates
Uncovering Lies About Disappearing Oil And Toxic Dispersants
BP Gulf Oil Spill Static Kill Has Failed
Evidence Mounts of BP Spraying Toxic Dispersants
New Report Shows BP Gulf Oil Spill Fishing

Related Posts

Post Navigation: